Papa John’s is currently testing a beta new spend based rewards program. Under the new program you receive 1 point per $1 spent and you can redeem 75 points for a $10 reward. Currently you earn one point for every $5 you spend and 25 points gets you a free pizza. Under the old program you would need to spend $125 to get a free pizza, under the new program you spend $75 and get a $10 reward. The better program would likely depend how expensive the free pizza you order is. It seems like the new program is invite only at this time.